Neurodivergent workers loathe “How are you?”—this humorous, evidence‑based guide explains why and offers practical workplace fixes.
The problem in plain (and painfully polite) English
Small talk is often a social ritual, not a real question; for many neurodivergent people it’s ambiguous, draining, and cognitively costly. Research and first‑person accounts show that superficial pleasantries can feel fake and force people into performance mode rather than honest exchange.
Why those questions sting
• Ambiguity overload: “How are you?” can be literal, rhetorical, or a preface to a request—neurodivergent brains prefer clear intent.
• Emotional labour: Answering requires rapid social decoding, masking, and sometimes invented small talk scripts—all of which are exhausting.
• Time and energy tax: Even a 30‑second exchange can deplete cognitive resources needed for focused work, especially for people with ADHD or autism.
A ‘lived’ field guide to answering (or not)
• Option A — The Literalist: “I am 72% functional; battery at 48%.” (Pros: honest. Cons: HR files a report.)
• Option B — The Stock Response: “Good, you?” (Pros: social lubricant. Cons: soul slowly evaporates.)
• Option C — The Tactical Redirect: “Busy—did you see the email about X?” (Pros: moves to purpose. Cons: may be judged as rude.)
• Option D — The Performance Art: Recite weekend itinerary in excruciating detail; watch colleagues’ eyes glaze. (Pros: catharsis. Cons: long lunch break required.)
What workplaces can do (without mandatory trust falls)
• Use clear conversational intent: Replace “How are you?” with “Do you have a minute?” or “Can I ask a quick question?” — this signals purpose and reduces ambiguity.
• Normalize directness: Encourage scripted alternatives like “I’m fine, thanks—quick question about X.”
• Create sensory‑friendly spaces: Quiet zones and predictable routines reduce the need for masking and make brief social exchanges less draining.
• Train managers: Teach simple communication swaps that respect neurodivergent needs—small changes yield big relief.
For neurodivergent folks: stock replies that preserve energy
• “All good—what’s up?” (short, redirects)
• “Fine, thanks. I’m heads‑down until 11:30.” (sets boundary)
• “Short on time today—can we make this quick?”
Closing (with a wink)
Small talk is meant to grease social wheels, but when it becomes a guessing game it grinds down people who prefer clarity. Treat “How are you?” like a polite knock—if someone knocks, say whether the door’s open. If not, maybe ask about the email instead. Live long, prosper, and may your workplace conversations come with labels and timestamps.
Leave a comment